R. Seth Williams: Three steps to make illegal guns like Kryptonite
Philadelphia set a record in 2021 with 562 murders. 2022 will most likely be worse. As of August 9th at midnight we had suffered 337 homicides, nine more or a three percent increase over 2021, the deadliest year in City history.
On August 1st, the murder count this year exceeded last year’s paceby a single killing. Among the murders that pushed this year ahead of last was the death from a stray bullet of a 29-year-old woman in Frankford who was sitting on her front porch barbequing with friends. A short time later, a van full of gunmen sprayed the entrance to SEPTA’s Arrott Transportation Center with dozens of bullets. The contagion of violence has exploded well beyond the confines of historically violent neighborhoods and groups.
Crime at major transportation centers like Arrott has become endemic. There have been multiple shootings, including at least one homicide, at the Clothespin at 15th and Market in Center City. There was a shooting in the 1700 block of JFK Boulevard. There was a mass shooting on South Street in the heart of the tourist and entertainment district. Gun violence is everywhere and is fast becoming our city’s brand. And with all too regular occurrence, young black and brown men are executing each other on our streets with five to twenty shots fired into each other’s heads and bodies.
People and businesses outside our city have no reason to come here, and those that are here have no reason to stay. It is hard to persuade remote workers to return to Center City when they see on the news that there are shootings in the stations where they catch the train and on the sidewalks where they walk to lunch. Suburban parents are not likely to send their children into our city for concerts and other events if they might be killed in transit. If the city is to survive and thrive, we need to change what we are doing. We need a bold response that matches the gravity of the moment.
The first step in every shooting is picking up a gun. What if in Philadelphia there were always significant legal and social consequences for carrying a gun? We should apply a consistent three-step process to gun possession; punish, shame, and rehabilitate.
Step One: Make guns like kryptonite?
For most of the past 50 years, illegally carrying a gun in Philadelphia has resulted in little or no legal consequences. From the 1970s through 1996, gun possession in Philadelphia was a misdemeanor prosecuted in the city’s equivalent to small claims court, Municipal Court. As young assistant District Attorneys, my colleagues and I engaged in a futile battle in Municipal Court to get jail sentences for gun possession only to have those rare sentences appealed to the Court of Common Pleas where the sentence was promptly vacated and adjusted to probation.
When I was elected DA, gun possession had already been upgraded to a felony. I worked with Mayor Nutter and Commissioner Ramsey to get more consistent bail and punishment for gun possession. It had a dramatic effect on gun violence, ushering in two consecutive years with record lows. But even during that period when we put an intense focus on gun possession cases, jail time was never close to a universal outcome.
What if we could credibly say to the young men carrying the guns: “If you carry a gun, you will go to jail”? We don’t have to speculate about the impact from that new reality. We know from years of research that the certainty of punishment has more impact on behavior than the severity of punishment.
Of course, the converse is true: the certainty of no punishment will have the opposite effect on behavior. Most Philadelphians would be shocked to know that there are individuals walking our streets today who have not one, not two, but as many as five or ten prior arrests for illegal gun possession.
And they never went to jail.
This is not a new phenomenon and not one that started with Larry Krasner. Krasner has made it exponentially worse by withdrawing, losing, or giving away a high percentage of gun cases and refusing to pursue probation violations for offenders on probation for gun offenses. But the city has never had a consistent policy of punishing gun possession.
What if we dramatically altered this dynamic?
The experience in New York City beginning in the mid-1990’s and up through Michael Bloomberg’s administration proved that aggressively enforcing gun laws will reduce gun violence. Does anyone remember Plaxico Burress? He was the pro football player caught with an illegal gun in New York City (he accidentally shot himself in a nightclub). Despite his money and celebrity, he went to jail for two years because the culture in New York City at that time did not tolerate people who illegally carried guns.
That lack of tolerance for illegal guns led to one of the steepest declines in homicides and shootings in the history of any city. New York City went from over 2,000 murders annually to less than 500. A city of eight million with fewer murders than Philadelphia, a city of 1.6 million! In recent years, the gun violence in New York has ticked back up as the legal culture has changed and become more lenient. The city has now stopped enforcing the two-year mandatory sentence that sent Burress to jail and — predictably — gun violence has increased dramatically.
Does Philadelphia have the will to do what New York City did? To adopt a policy and culture that does not tolerate illegal guns? One way to get there is through mandatory sentencing.
State law contains a Philadelphia-only statute that could easily be made into a mandatory sentence. Section 6108 applies to cities of the First Class only. Philadelphia is the only city of the First Class in Pennsylvania. By making Section 6108 a mandatory minimum of two years, or even one, the state legislature would ensure that carrying a gun in Philadelphia — the city with the worst murder and violence problems — would carry certain and severe consequences.
This change would only impact our city so theoretically other county legislators would have no reason to oppose it. Yes, I am advocating mandatory jail time for Philadelphians who illegally carry guns because I know that it is not the severity of punishment that prevents crime it is the certainty and mandatory sentences provide a level of certainty. I changed office policies and demandatorized many drug cases. But if you are willing to carry a gun illegally, we need to send you to jail before you kill. “Gotta go, gotta go!”
Of course, Krasner and the courts do not need to wait for Harrisburg to act to change the culture around guns. They could begin imposing jail sentences for gun possession without the intervention of the legislature and any change to the law. Our city council, police commissioner and mayor also do not have to wait to act. They could advocate immediately for jail sentences in gun cases as both a broad policy through their public rhetoric and in individual cases by going to court and asking to speak about the impact of guns on our communities at sentencing hearings. Mayor Rendell did this in the 90’s, having representatives go to courts to talk about the impact of car thefts. The 2023 Mayoral candidates could all adopt policy positions seeking to impose harsh penalties for the mere possession of an illegal firearm.
When I publish these opinions, I always expect to be vilified by the far left as well as the far right because I call out how morally bankrupt both of their political orthodoxies are. The rightwing will likely object to a mandatory sentence for gun possession because it violates their policy of creating zero obstructions to flooding the streets with guns.
The far left which reflexively opposes any law enforcement focused efforts will argue against “mass incarceration” or as Larry Krasner says: “replacing the war on drugs with a war on guns.” and “prosecuting illegal gun possession criminalizes poverty.” No doubt poverty and hopelessness contribute to crime and violence, but even Larry can separate the “I am poor and hopeless” group from the “I can do whatever the F*#k I want” group. I have to believe the individuals throwing bullets down a residential block in Frankford and killing an innocent woman on her front porch, fall into the latter category.
But regardless of whether those shooters are poor and desperate or depraved and malevolent the consequences for their actions will be the same; they will spend the rest of their natural lives in prison for murder. Isn’t two years in prison for gun possession better than life in prison for a murder? Wouldn’t putting more people in jail for a few years for gun possession result in less people going to jail for life for murder?
Krasner brags about the 28,000 fewer years of incarceration imposed in Philadelphia since he became District Attorney. But under his regime, Philadelphia still has the highest number of citizens in the state who are eligible for long prison sentences or life in prison because we have the highest number of citizens carrying and using illegal guns. Since Krasner took office there have been over 2000 murders (2,092 as of August 2nd ). Each of those murders has the potential to result in a life sentence.
Likewise, shootings have increased dramatically under Krasner creating another category for a large number of long prison sentences. So looked at more broadly, consistent harsh punishment for gun possession may actually reduce incarceration levels. In New York City when they cracked down on gun possession, they actually saw their prison population at Rikers Island decline because there was less serious crime occurring.
Did Plaxico Burress have to go to jail? Yes, he did, in order to maintain a community standard; Don’t carry illegal guns. If you do, you will go to jail. Make guns like kryptonite and see what happens to our city’s gun violence. We have nothing to lose if we have the courage to take this bold step.
Step Two: Make the gun possessors lepers in their community
What if in addition to punishing gun possession we shamed those that are guilty of that crime? In many communities, they publicize the arrest of drunk drivers, child predators, and “johns” who patronize prostitutes. What if we did the same with guns? Put their pictures online with captions like “Afraid to fight so he hides behind a gun” or “Coward who hurts his community by carrying a gun.” Use social media to embarrass the same young men who currently wear their arrest records and association with violence as a badge of honor.
I know the power of public shame. I saw my face and name in the media and continue to face condemnation and scorn as a result of the past (this article will likely ignite a storm of Seth Williams-shaming on Twitter — it happens every time). It is not fun and I don’t care who you are, it has an impact. We could enlist celebrities in the effort. Maybe hearing that guns are for punks from Brandon Graham will have more of an impact than likes for violent videos on Instagram.
We all condemn people arrested for gun violence and we abhor the guns themselves but we do little to condemn the people carrying the guns before they use them. We have it exactly backwards. We put millions of dollars in resources toward investigating, prosecuting, and housing murderers for life but we do nothing when they show the first sign of being a murderer by carrying a gun.
Step Three: Rehabilitation
Rehabilitation is likely to have more success early in the criminal career if punishment is certain and society sends a clear message that the culture of the gun is unacceptable. People are more likely to leave a culture that is scorned than one that is glorified. Within the community, there is a collective agreement that using guns to hurt others is unacceptable but we are not having an argument directly with the folks carrying the guns.
Let’s start an argument about whether people who carry guns are tough and glamorous or weak and selfish. As a society, we should be able to win that argument but we have to start it first.
R. Seth Williams is the former district attorney for Philadelphia, and was the first African American elected as a district attorney anywhere in the commonwealth. Follow him on Twitter at @newsethwilliams.
Seth,
I always look forward to your articles and opinions. You are a great resource and the politicians in this City should seek your counsel on this Epidemic.
Thank you, for putting yourself out there.
Well, if what you say above doesn’t work out, you could always bribe them into doing the right thing, right?
http://www.cbsnews.com/news/seth-williams-former-philadelphia-district-attorney-gets-prison-term-bribe/
Gee, thanks for giving us a history lesson…now enlighten me: What does that have to do with this subject.
Nada.. but did you learn something about the person who wrote the article? Do you trust him MORE or LESS after reading it? Does he have credibility? Do you trust him?
Again, you point to the history of the writer, as a Philadelphian, I am aware of his history including incarceration and his intelligent thoughts on the crisis in our City as well as the shortcomings and arrogance of our current DA.
What are your ideas? What’s your evidence to support your ideas? I see a lot of tear downs & what about isms in your comments. How about something constructive? And bybthecway, yes January 6th was a lot worse. It’s intent was to destroy our democracy with lies and violence.
There’s a lack of fearlessness in the collective effort to make change in behavior when we are not doing the work we are required to do. Collectively and compassionately we should forgive our own past transgressions and stop seeing each other as our mistakes and start minding the right kind of business in our own neighborhoods that are not making the city safe. Everyone has a responsibility to make change.
Year after year 80% of the killings in Philadelphia are black on black killings. For example last year there were 562 homicides in Philadelphia, so approximately 449 of those killings were committed by blacks and the victims were black. I think it’s time to bring back the stop and frisk policy. I would rather have my 16 year old teenager frisked by the police, than have a homicide detective knock on my door to tell me my son or daughter is at the morgue waiting for a parent identification.
Once again Seth Williams has proposed actions that have the ability to save lives in Philadelphia. Too often the politicians have focused on interventions that only affect the folks who don’t carry illegal firearms. That’s why I like his focus on enforcement and incarceration first to stem the tide. Once punishment is certain then rehabilitation has a chance
Since the right is apparently so worried about crime and violence (and so supportive of law enforcement) are you going to write any stories about the numerous wacko right-wingers openly planning to murder more law enforcement officers at the FBI? The Trumper who opened fire on the FBI in Cincinnati? The open calls for civil war on Twitter, Gab, and Pravda (I mean “Truth”)? The violent gang of thugs who stormed and looted the capitol on 1/6 or the decision by the RNC to officially endorse their deadly violence as “legitimate political discourse”?
Yeah, okay.. keep drinking your kool-aid.
Start doing some REAL detective work, instead of gorging on the trough of pig slop the main stream media keeps feeding the sheeple. Oink Oink.
“Gangs and thugs.”. wow…. angry much?
Hmm.. guess those “gangs and thugs” on Jan 6th were worse than this? And this is just ONE of many many many examples. And NOBODY was locked up for more than a few days. Talk about a joke! Who attacked law enforcement during THOSE peaceful protests? ANYONE? Give me a break…
http://www.npr.org/2020/08/03/898703442/protest-and-a-black-owned-business
I don’t believe anyone would claim that Seth Williams is a right winger. His pieces are thoughtful and deserve fair consideration. He has paid for his crimes and has a pointof view that few of us can compare to. He makes good points.
When the total death toll from these threats approaches an average summer weekend in Philadelphia we will all support your proposed focus.
Do yourself a favor and look up “Project Exile” – done in Richmond, VA in the 1990’s.
It was backed by the NRA and coordinated state and federal prosecutions for firearms related aspects of crime. Federal penalties for illegal guns are substantial.
Result? There was a quick and massive reduction in gun crimes in Richmond during the experiment.
So I’m guessing you don’t live in West Philly or near Kensington. So you’re one of those mainline guys or chestnut hill residents.